Why can't Richardson beat out struggling Jones as Colts QB1?

INDIANAPOLIS -- Indianapolis Colts teammates Anthony Richardson Sr. and Grover Stewart have a playful rivalry that can be seen playing out during practice most days.

Stewart, the 6-foot-4, 314-pound veteran nose tackle who anchors the middle of the defense, warns backup quarterback Richardson that today is the day he'll chase him down when he leaves the pocket.

"Look," Stewart said, "he can move. But I always tell him, 'I'm gonna catch you.'"

Stewart rarely does.

"Hey, he's a hard guy to catch," Stewart said. "He's fast. That's a threat right there. Big arm, big legs."

But lately, those practice reps running the scout-team offense are the closest Richardson has come to playing meaningful snaps. That remains true despite starting quarterback Daniel Jones ranking as the NFL's worst starter in numerous major categories, including QBR (30.3) and yards per attempt (5.6). He also leads the NFL in interceptions (12).

Nevertheless, Jones remains the starter heading into Thursday's AFC South matchup against the Houston Texans (8:15 ET, Prime Video). And Colts coach Shane Steichen continues to defend his handpicked starter who enjoyed the best stretch of his career under Steichen in the first half of the 2025 season.

But most of what Jones has displayed in 2026 suggests that last season -- he at one point was the most efficient passer in the NFL -- was the exception, not the rule. Jones posted a 1.7 QBR in Sunday's win over the Miami Dolphins, the worst of any quarterback who has started a game in 2026. He's averaged 135 passing yards in his past four games and hasn't thrown for 200 yards in any game in the last month. It is arguably the worst Jones has played in his career, including his six tumultuous seasons with the New York Giants.

But Steichen remains steadfast.

"I think I take everything into account," he said when asked how he determines whether a quarterback change is warranted. "I always go back and look at the film and make sure on this play, was it his fault? Was it someone else's fault? I think there's a lot that goes into it.

"Obviously, the biggest thing is taking care of the football moving forward."

Jones hasn't done the latter, with a 7-to-12 touchdown-to-interception ratio and 13 fumbles over his 23 games as the Colts' starter. To be fair, the Colts are outmanned on offense, especially after trading receivers Josh Downs and Keenan Allen last week and All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson late last month.

But there's no spinning Jones' performance, which was problematic even before the Colts' recent flurry of trades. The Colts fired general manager Chris Ballard on Oct. 19, lost five of their past six games and are four games behind division-leading Jacksonville in the win column. If now isn't the time to try someone else at quarterback, when will it be?

"It's not all about one guy," Steichen said this week. "I think it takes all 11 to do their job at a high level."

It's a level of grace the Colts rarely afforded to Richardson.

The No. 4 overall pick in the 2023 draft, Richardson's arrival in Indianapolis coincided with Steichen's. Together, the team envisioned Steichen doing for Richardson what he'd done for other young quarterbacks such as Justin Herbert and Jalen Hurts while an offensive coordinator for the Chargers and Eagles, respectively.

Steichen, along with Ballard and late owner Jim Irsay, were aligned on the selection of Richardson, who had just 13 college starts at Florida. He was one of the least-experienced quarterbacks ever to be drafted in the first round, but the Colts were undaunted.

Richardson entered his first training camp in competition with veteran Gardner Minshew II. Richardson started the team's preseason opener that summer against the Buffalo Bills and played about a quarter. Two days later, Steichen opened his post-practice media briefing with an announcement: He'd seen enough. Richardson would be the team's Week 1 starter.

Steichen, it seemed, was all-in.

Now, four seasons later, Richardson, who is in the last year of his contract, can't get on the field even when the team's starter is throwing perplexing interceptions and his coach's job is in serious jeopardy.

Looking back, Steichen's belief in Richardson was short-lived. Steichen benched Richardson midway through the 2024 season following a loss at Houston that included the infamous "tap out," with Richardson leaving the game for a play after taking a knee on the field. He later said he was exhausted after the previous play.

Steichen insisted then that backup Joe Flacco gave the Colts the best chance to win -- until that proved not to be true. Three weeks later, Steichen reinserted Richardson into the lineup. He went on to have some promising moments, authoring game-winning drives against the New York Jets and New England Patriots down the stretch.

But Richardson's inconsistency -- he's a 50.9% career passer -- and his many injuries seemed to break Steichen's belief. It was clear to many in the organization that the coach had turned the page on the young quarterback. The Colts signed Jones the following spring and the rest is history. He has since signed a two-year, $88 million contract extension that might be a variable in Steichen's commitment to Jones.

Richardson's performance was more than enough to prompt the Colts to look elsewhere. He was one of the lowest-rated quarterbacks in the league in his lone season as a full-time starter. But the same is now true of Jones, yet Steichen is staying the course.

Steichen recently acknowledged that Richardson's electric running ability could possibly give the Colts a spark. Richardson has 10 rushing touchdowns in 15 career starts.

"That's a real thing," Steichen said. "... We'll look at everything."

The Colts have at least considered it. Richardson, according to multiple sources, currently has a package of plays in the playbook. But the Colts have yet to dust it off. If his exploits against Colts defenders in practice are any indication, perhaps they should.

"He's so explosive," defensive end Jaylahn Tuimoloau said. "I don't think I've ever played against a quarterback that explosive. He gives us great looks on the scout team whenever we go against him."

Richardson showed improvement during the preseason after coming back from a career-threatening eye injury that kept him out for much of last season. Still, it's difficult to imagine a future for him in Indianapolis. Recognizing his status with the franchise, Richardson requested a trade earlier this year. Ultimately, nothing materialized, according to team sources. But that the idea was even broached spoke volumes about Richardson's view of the situation. Now, Ballard, Richardson's biggest ally at Colts headquarters, has been ousted.

Richardson was recently cited for marijuana possession in Carmel, Indiana, and faces a possible four-game suspension for violating the personal conduct policy, but there's no indication that is playing a role in lineup decisions.

"I've just got to keep doing what I've been doing, coming in the building, showing up to work," Richardson said recently. "Just preparing like I was going to be the starter regardless of what decision [Steichen] makes. I've just got to make sure I'm prepared when my number's called."

At this point, it's not clear whether that will ever happen.