Suffering for his own versatility, many saw Phil Neville as Manchester United’s utility man. Struggling for first-team football, Neville joined Everton in 2005. Following his arrival, David Moyes made him club captain. To his credit, Neville has proven an astute purchase. Vocal and determined, Neville’s leadership qualities were clear from day one.
Despite his undoubted qualities, the recent use of Neville in midfield has coincided with fans questioning his place in the side. A capable right back, Neville lacks the required attributes for midfield. In possession, there is an absence of touch, technique and vision. Another flaw is the understandable unwillingness to seek possession. As expected, Neville’s attacking output is minimal with one shot and one chance created.
Lacking in attacking ability, defensive work is the marker by which to judge Neville. Unfortunately, Neville also falls down on the defensive aspects. Poor positional sense and slack marking lead to rash tackles and a failure to track runners.
A return of four tackles in four matches is not enough. Highlighted by team-mate comparisons, it is clear that Neville is not doing enough. Steven Pienaar has attempted the same number of tackles whilst Nikica Jelavic has identical statistics. Known for his attacking capabilities, Leon Osman has made more tackles, clearances and headed clearances.
In possession, Everton are able with most players comfortable on the ball. Defensively, teams are beginning to cut through the midfield with alarming regularity. The last two league fixtures against Newcastle and West Brom have exposed the soft underbelly of the Everton midfield. Lacking strength and stamina, Osman and Neville are easily outfought.
With Neville’s unsuitability for midfield and Everton’s failure to win their last two matches, it is imperative that Marouane Fellaini returns to the heart of the midfield. Used in an advanced role, Everton miss the Belgian’s physical presence and tackling ability. Regardless of Darron Gibson’s injury, Fellaini remains best in central midfield. Repositioning of Fellaini would also allow Neville to revert to right back.
With his crossing, aerial ability and leadership, Neville remains a viable option at right back. Clearly unsuitable for midfield, Neville still offers a lot as a defender. Those traits, coupled with his experience, show that Neville is still a valued member of the squad. His days as a guaranteed starter are reaching an end but he can still contribute as Everton move forward this season.
After seven years at Everton, few can question Neville’s efforts since signing. Since his transfer, Neville has proved the doubters wrong and enjoyed impressive nights in Everton colours. Sadly, time catches up with all and Neville turns 36 in February. The 22nd oldest player in Everton history, Neville is entering the twilight of his long and illustrious career. Over the last 18 months, time has begun to catch up with Neville and some would argue it has overtaken him.