| 1. Christian Yelich Mil, LF | OF1 | OF | Team Kaiser |
| 2. Ronald Acuna Jr. Atl, LF | OF2 | OF | Team Nitzberg |
| 3. Gerrit Cole NYY, SP | SP1 | SP | Team Mass |
| 4. Mookie Betts LAD, RF | OF3 | OF | Team Zola |
| 5. Cody Bellinger LAD, RF | OF4 | 1B,OF | Derek Carty |
| 6. Mike Trout LAA, CF | OF5 | OF | Team Soppe |
| 7. Francisco Lindor Cle, SS | SS1 | SS | Team Becquey |
| 8. Trea Turner Wsh, SS | SS2 | SS | Team Bonzagni |
| 9. Jacob deGrom NYM, SP | SP2 | SP | Team Cockcroft |
| 10. Juan Soto Wsh, LF | OF6 | OF | Team Karabell |
| 11. Alex Bregman Hou, 3B | 3B1 | 3B,SS | Team Karabell |
| 12. Nolan Arenado Col, 3B | 3B2 | 3B | Team Cockcroft |
| 13. Max Scherzer Wsh, SP | SP3 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 14. Justin Verlander Hou, SP | SP4 | SP | Team Becquey |
| 15. Jose Ramirez Cle, 3B | 3B3 | 3B | Team Soppe |
| 16. Trevor Story Col, SS | SS3 | SS | Derek Carty |
| 17. J.D. Martinez Bos, LF | OF7 | OF,DH | Team Zola |
| 18. Walker Buehler LAD, SP | SP5 | SP | Team Mass |
| 19. Stephen Strasburg Wsh, SP | SP6 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 20. Rafael Devers Bos, 3B | 3B4 | 3B | Team Kaiser |
| 21. Bryce Harper Phi, RF | OF8 | OF | Team Kaiser |
| 22. Javier Baez ChC, SS | SS4 | SS | Team Nitzberg |
| 23. Pete Alonso NYM, 1B | 1B1 | 1B | Team Mass |
| 24. Mike Clevinger Cle, SP | SP7 | SP | Team Zola |
| 25. Clayton Kershaw LAD, SP | SP8 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 26. Starling Marte Ari, CF | OF9 | OF | Team Soppe |
| 27. Freddie Freeman Atl, 1B | 1B2 | 1B | Team Becquey |
| 28. Anthony Rendon LAA, 3B | 3B5 | 3B | Team Bonzagni |
| 29. Fernando Tatis Jr. SD, SS | SS5 | SS | Team Cockcroft |
| 30. Jack Flaherty StL, SP | SP9 | SP | Team Karabell |
| 31. Shane Bieber Cle, SP | SP10 | SP | Team Karabell |
| 32. Jose Altuve Hou, 2B | 2B1 | 2B | Team Cockcroft |
| 33. Charlie Blackmon Col, CF | OF10 | OF | Team Bonzagni |
| 34. Ozzie Albies Atl, 2B | 2B2 | 2B | Team Becquey |
| 35. Patrick Corbin Wsh, SP | SP11 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 36. Manny Machado SD, 3B | 3B6 | 3B,SS | Derek Carty |
| 37. Ketel Marte Ari, CF | OF11 | 2B,OF | Team Zola |
| 38. Nelson Cruz Min, DH | DH1 | DH | Team Mass |
| 39. George Springer Hou, CF | OF12 | OF | Team Nitzberg |
| 40. Xander Bogaerts Bos, SS | SS6 | SS | Team Kaiser |
| 41. Gleyber Torres NYY, SS | SS7 | 2B,SS | Team Kaiser |
| 42. Matt Olson Oak, 1B | 1B3 | 1B | Team Nitzberg |
| 43. Anthony Rizzo ChC, 1B | 1B4 | 1B | Team Mass |
| 44. Zack Greinke Hou, SP | SP12 | SP | Team Zola |
| 45. Blake Snell TB, SP | SP13 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 46. Keston Hiura Mil, 2B | 2B3 | 2B | Team Soppe |
| 47. Charlie Morton TB, SP | SP14 | SP | Team Becquey |
| 48. Joey Gallo Tex, LF | OF13 | OF | Team Bonzagni |
| 49. Austin Meadows TB, RF | OF14 | OF,DH | Team Cockcroft |
| 50. Yordan Alvarez Hou, DH | DH2 | DH | Team Karabell |
| 51. Kris Bryant ChC, 3B | 3B7 | 3B,OF | Team Karabell |
| 52. Jonathan Villar Mia, 2B | 2B4 | 2B,SS | Team Cockcroft |
| 53. Luis Castillo Cin, SP | SP15 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 54. Giancarlo Stanton NYY, RF | OF15 | OF | Team Becquey |
| 55. Lucas Giolito ChW, SP | SP16 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 56. Josh Hader Mil, RP | RP1 | RP | Derek Carty |
| 57. Marcus Semien Oak, SS | SS8 | SS | Team Zola |
| 58. Bo Bichette Tor, SS | SS9 | SS | Team Mass |
| 59. Aaron Judge NYY, RF | OF16 | OF | Team Nitzberg |
| 60. Kirby Yates SD, RP | RP2 | RP | Team Kaiser |
| 61. Aroldis Chapman NYY, RP | RP3 | RP | Team Kaiser |
| 62. Chris Paddack SD, SP | SP17 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 63. Whit Merrifield KC, 2B | 2B5 | 2B,OF | Team Mass |
| 64. Jose Abreu ChW, 1B | 1B5 | 1B,DH | Team Zola |
| 65. Victor Robles Wsh, CF | OF17 | OF | Derek Carty |
| 66. Eddie Rosario Min, LF | OF18 | OF | Team Soppe |
| 67. Eloy Jimenez ChW, LF | OF19 | OF | Team Becquey |
| 68. Eugenio Suarez Cin, 3B | 3B8 | 3B | Team Bonzagni |
| 69. Paul Goldschmidt StL, 1B | 1B6 | 1B | Team Cockcroft |
| 70. Tommy Pham SD, CF | OF20 | OF,DH | Team Karabell |
| 71. Carlos Correa Hou, SS | SS10 | SS | Team Karabell |
| 72. Roberto Osuna Hou, RP | RP4 | RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 73. Tyler Glasnow TB, SP | SP18 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 74. DJ LeMahieu NYY, 2B | 2B6 | 1B,2B,3B | Team Becquey |
| 75. Marcell Ozuna Atl, LF | OF21 | OF | Team Soppe |
| 76. Yoan Moncada ChW, 3B | 3B9 | 3B | Derek Carty |
| 77. Matt Chapman Oak, 3B | 3B10 | 3B | Team Zola |
| 78. J.T. Realmuto Phi, C | C1 | C | Team Mass |
| 79. Yu Darvish ChC, SP | SP19 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 80. Josh Bell Pit, 1B | 1B7 | 1B | Team Kaiser |
| 81. Shohei Ohtani LAA, DH | DH3 | DH,SP | Team Kaiser |
| 82. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Tor, 3B | 3B11 | 3B,DH | Team Nitzberg |
| 83. Edwin Diaz NYM, RP | RP5 | RP | Team Mass |
| 84. Nicholas Castellanos Cin, RF | OF22 | OF | Team Zola |
| 85. Max Muncy LAD, 2B | 2B7 | 1B,2B,3B | Derek Carty |
| 86. Liam Hendriks Oak, RP | RP6 | RP | Team Soppe |
| 87. Aaron Nola Phi, SP | SP20 | SP | Team Becquey |
| 88. Kyle Schwarber ChC, LF | OF23 | OF | Team Bonzagni |
| 89. Michael Conforto NYM, LF | OF24 | OF | Team Cockcroft |
| 90. Adalberto Mondesi KC, SS | SS11 | SS | Team Karabell |
| 91. Jorge Soler KC, RF | OF25 | OF,DH | Team Karabell |
| 92. Ramon Laureano Oak, CF | OF26 | OF | Team Cockcroft |
| 93. Jeff McNeil NYM, LF | OF27 | 2B,3B,OF | Team Bonzagni |
| 94. Josh Donaldson Min, 3B | 3B12 | 3B | Team Becquey |
| 95. Brandon Woodruff Mil, SP | SP21 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 96. Jesus Luzardo Oak, RP | RP7 | RP | Derek Carty |
| 97. Jose Berrios Min, SP | SP22 | SP | Team Zola |
| 98. Trevor Bauer Cin, SP | SP23 | SP | Team Mass |
| 99. Taylor Rogers Min, RP | RP8 | RP | Team Nitzberg |
| 100. Corey Kluber Tex, SP | SP24 | SP | Team Kaiser |
| 101. Carlos Carrasco Cle, SP | SP25 | SP,RP | Team Kaiser |
| 102. Franmil Reyes Cle, RF | OF28 | OF,DH | Team Nitzberg |
| 103. Kenley Jansen LAD, RP | RP9 | RP | Team Mass |
| 104. Mike Minor Tex, SP | SP26 | SP | Team Zola |
| 105. Andrew Benintendi Bos, LF | OF29 | OF | Derek Carty |
| 106. Luis Robert ChW, CF | OF30 | OF | Team Soppe |
| 107. Mike Moustakas Cin, 3B | 3B13 | 2B,3B | Team Becquey |
| 108. Brad Hand Cle, RP | RP10 | RP | Team Bonzagni |
| 109. Gary Sanchez NYY, C | C2 | C | Team Cockcroft |
| 110. Ken Giles Tor, RP | RP11 | RP | Team Karabell |
| 111. Nick Anderson TB, RP | RP12 | RP | Team Karabell |
| 112. Michael Brantley Hou, LF | OF31 | OF,DH | Team Cockcroft |
| 113. Craig Kimbrel ChC, RP | RP13 | RP | Team Bonzagni |
| 114. Miguel Sano Min, 3B | 3B14 | 3B | Team Becquey |
| 115. Sonny Gray Cin, SP | SP27 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 116. James Paxton NYY, SP | SP28 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 117. Hyun-Jin Ryu Tor, SP | SP29 | SP | Team Zola |
| 118. David Dahl Col, LF | OF32 | OF | Team Mass |
| 119. Rhys Hoskins Phi, 1B | 1B8 | 1B | Team Nitzberg |
| 120. Carlos Santana Cle, 1B | 1B9 | 1B,DH | Team Kaiser |
| 121. Raisel Iglesias Cin, RP | RP14 | RP | Team Kaiser |
| 122. Mike Soroka Atl, SP | SP30 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 123. Tommy Edman StL, 3B | 3B15 | 2B,3B | Team Mass |
| 124. Hansel Robles LAA, RP | RP15 | RP | Team Zola |
| 125. Justin Turner LAD, 3B | 3B16 | 3B | Derek Carty |
| 126. Tim Anderson ChW, SS | SS12 | SS | Team Soppe |
| 127. Lance Lynn Tex, SP | SP31 | SP | Team Becquey |
| 128. Byron Buxton Min, CF | OF33 | OF | Team Bonzagni |
| 129. Max Kepler Min, RF | OF34 | OF | Team Cockcroft |
| 130. Julio Urias LAD, RP | RP16 | SP,RP | Team Karabell |
| 131. Lourdes Gurriel Jr. Tor, LF | OF35 | OF | Team Karabell |
| 132. Frankie Montas Oak, SP | SP32 | SP | Team Cockcroft |
| 133. Zack Wheeler Phi, SP | SP33 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 134. Yasmani Grandal ChW, C | C3 | C,1B | Team Becquey |
| 135. Brandon Workman Bos, RP | RP17 | RP | Team Soppe |
| 136. Willson Contreras ChC, C | C4 | C | Derek Carty |
| 137. Wilson Ramos NYM, C | C5 | C | Team Zola |
| 138. Sean Doolittle Wsh, RP | RP18 | RP | Team Mass |
| 139. Eduardo Escobar Ari, 3B | 3B17 | 2B,3B | Team Nitzberg |
| 140. Oscar Mercado Cle, CF | OF36 | OF | Team Kaiser |
| 141. Kyle Hendricks ChC, SP | SP34 | SP | Team Kaiser |
| 142. Alex Colome ChW, RP | RP19 | RP | Team Nitzberg |
| 143. Andrew McCutchen Phi, RF | OF37 | OF | Team Mass |
| 144. Madison Bumgarner Ari, SP | SP35 | SP | Team Zola |
| 145. Lance McCullers Jr. Hou, SP | SP36 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 146. Edwin Encarnacion ChW, 1B | 1B10 | 1B,DH | Team Soppe |
| 147. Matthew Boyd Det, SP | SP37 | SP | Team Becquey |
| 148. Archie Bradley Ari, RP | RP20 | RP | Team Bonzagni |
| 149. Hector Neris Phi, RP | RP21 | RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 150. Howie Kendrick Wsh, 1B | 1B11 | 1B,2B | Team Karabell |
| 151. Luis Arraez Min, 2B | 2B8 | 2B,OF | Team Karabell |
| 152. Corey Seager LAD, SS | SS13 | SS | Team Cockcroft |
| 153. Gavin Lux LAD, 2B | 2B9 | 2B | Team Bonzagni |
| 154. Zac Gallen Ari, SP | SP38 | SP | Team Becquey |
| 155. Khris Davis Oak, DH | DH4 | DH | Team Soppe |
| 156. Ryan Braun Mil, LF | OF38 | OF | Derek Carty |
| 157. Jose Leclerc Tex, RP | RP22 | RP | Team Zola |
| 158. Dinelson Lamet SD, SP | SP39 | SP | Team Mass |
| 159. Mitch Garver Min, C | C6 | C | Team Nitzberg |
| 160. Jorge Polanco Min, SS | SS14 | SS | Team Kaiser |
| 161. Sean Manaea Oak, SP | SP40 | SP | Team Kaiser |
| 162. Max Fried Atl, SP | SP41 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 163. A.J. Puk Oak, RP | RP23 | RP | Team Mass |
| 164. Hunter Renfroe TB, LF | OF39 | OF | Team Zola |
| 165. Eduardo Rodriguez Bos, SP | SP42 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 166. Robbie Ray Ari, SP | SP43 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 167. Joc Pederson LAD, LF | OF40 | 1B,OF | Team Becquey |
| 168. Yuli Gurriel Hou, 1B | 1B12 | 1B,3B | Team Bonzagni |
| 169. Kenta Maeda Min, SP | SP44 | SP,RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 170. Luke Weaver Ari, SP | SP45 | SP | Team Karabell |
| 171. Josh James Hou, RP | RP24 | RP | Team Karabell |
| 172. J.D. Davis NYM, LF | OF41 | 3B,OF | Team Cockcroft |
| 173. Will Smith LAD, C | C7 | C | Team Bonzagni |
| 174. Justin Upton LAA, LF | OF42 | OF | Team Becquey |
| 175. Amed Rosario NYM, SS | SS15 | SS | Team Soppe |
| 176. Avisail Garcia Mil, RF | OF43 | OF,DH | Derek Carty |
| 177. Ross Stripling LAD, RP | RP25 | SP,RP | Team Zola |
| 178. Bryan Reynolds Pit, CF | OF44 | OF | Team Mass |
| 179. Joe Jimenez Det, RP | RP26 | RP | Team Nitzberg |
| 180. Adam Eaton Wsh, RF | OF45 | OF | Team Kaiser |
| 181. Keone Kela Pit, RP | RP27 | RP | Team Kaiser |
| 182. Willie Calhoun Tex, LF | OF46 | OF | Team Nitzberg |
| 183. Garrett Hampson Col, 2B | 2B10 | 2B,OF | Team Mass |
| 184. C.J. Cron Det, 1B | 1B13 | 1B | Team Zola |
| 185. Carlos Martinez StL, RP | RP28 | RP | Derek Carty |
| 186. German Marquez Col, SP | SP46 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 187. Lorenzo Cain Mil, CF | OF47 | OF | Team Becquey |
| 188. Aaron Hicks NYY, CF | OF48 | OF | Team Bonzagni |
| 189. Ian Kennedy KC, RP | RP29 | RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 190. Nate Pearson Tor, SP | SP47 | SP | Team Karabell |
| 191. MacKenzie Gore SD, SP | SP48 | SP | Team Karabell |
| 192. Giovanny Gallegos StL, RP | RP30 | RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 193. Mike Foltynewicz Atl, SP | SP49 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 194. Mark Melancon Atl, RP | RP31 | RP | Team Becquey |
| 195. Christian Vazquez Bos, C | C8 | C | Team Soppe |
| 196. Paul DeJong StL, SS | SS16 | SS | Derek Carty |
| 197. Cavan Biggio Tor, 2B | 2B11 | 2B | Team Zola |
| 198. Wander Franco TB, SS | SS17 | SS | Team Mass |
| 199. Jake Odorizzi Min, SP | SP50 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 200. Jose Urquidy Hou, SP | SP51 | SP | Team Kaiser |
| 201. Starlin Castro Wsh, 2B | 2B12 | 2B,3B | Team Kaiser |
| 202. Rich Hill Min, SP | SP52 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 203. Marcus Stroman NYM, SP | SP53 | SP | Team Mass |
| 204. Brian Anderson Mia, 3B | 3B18 | 3B,OF | Team Zola |
| 205. Andrew Heaney LAA, SP | SP54 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 206. Danny Santana Tex, LF | OF49 | 1B,OF | Team Soppe |
| 207. Will Smith Atl, RP | RP32 | RP | Team Becquey |
| 208. Ryan Yarbrough TB, RP | RP33 | SP,RP | Team Bonzagni |
| 209. Joe Musgrove Pit, SP | SP55 | SP | Team Cockcroft |
| 210. Seth Lugo NYM, RP | RP34 | RP | Team Karabell |
| 211. Masahiro Tanaka NYY, SP | SP56 | SP | Team Karabell |
| 212. Dallas Keuchel ChW, SP | SP57 | SP | Team Cockcroft |
| 213. Miguel Andujar NYY, DH | DH5 | DH | Team Bonzagni |
| 214. Kyle Tucker Hou, LF | OF50 | OF | Team Becquey |
| 215. Reynaldo Lopez ChW, SP | SP58 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 216. Brandon Lowe TB, 2B | 2B13 | 2B | Derek Carty |
| 217. Alex Verdugo Bos, RF | OF51 | OF | Team Zola |
| 218. Kevin Kiermaier TB, CF | OF52 | OF | Team Mass |
| 219. Luke Voit NYY, 1B | 1B14 | 1B,DH | Team Nitzberg |
| 220. Omar Narvaez Mil, C | C9 | C | Team Kaiser |
| 221. Hunter Dozier KC, 3B | 3B19 | 3B,OF | Team Kaiser |
| 222. Jordan Montgomery NYY, SP | SP59 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 223. Shogo Akiyama Cin, CF | OF53 | OF | Team Mass |
| 224. Trent Grisham SD, RF | OF54 | OF | Team Zola |
| 225. A.J. Pollock LAD, CF | OF55 | OF | Derek Carty |
| 226. Caleb Smith Mia, SP | SP60 | SP | Team Soppe |
| 227. Randal Grichuk Tor, RF | OF56 | OF | Team Becquey |
| 228. Dylan Bundy LAA, SP | SP61 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 229. Daniel Murphy Col, 1B | 1B15 | 1B | Team Cockcroft |
| 230. Dylan Carlson StL, RF | OF57 | OF | Team Karabell |
| 231. Scott Kingery Phi, CF | OF58 | 3B,OF | Team Karabell |
| 232. Yonny Chirinos TB, SP | SP62 | SP,RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 233. Jon Gray Col, SP | SP63 | SP | Team Bonzagni |
| 234. Tony Watson SF, RP | RP35 | RP | Team Becquey |
| 235. Dellin Betances NYM, RP | RP36 | RP | Team Soppe |
| 236. Brendan McKay TB, SP | SP64 | SP | Derek Carty |
| 237. Chris Bassitt Oak, SP | SP65 | SP | Team Zola |
| 238. Jo Adell LAA, CF | OF59 | OF | Team Mass |
| 239. Carter Kieboom Wsh, SS | SS18 | SS | Team Nitzberg |
| 240. Brad Peacock Hou, SP | SP66 | SP,RP | Team Kaiser |
| 241. Gio Urshela NYY, 3B | 3B20 | 3B | Team Kaiser |
| 242. Griffin Canning LAA, SP | SP67 | SP | Team Nitzberg |
| 243. Casey Mize Det, SP | SP68 | SP | Team Mass |
| 244. Adrian Houser Mil, SP | SP69 | SP,RP | Team Zola |
| 245. Nick Senzel Cin, CF | OF60 | OF | Derek Carty |
| 246. Tyler Chatwood ChC, RP | RP37 | SP,RP | Team Soppe |
| 247. Dansby Swanson Atl, SS | SS19 | SS | Team Becquey |
| 248. Joey Votto Cin, 1B | 1B16 | 1B | Team Bonzagni |
| 249. Ryan Pressly Hou, RP | RP38 | RP | Team Cockcroft |
| 250. Salvador Perez KC, C | C10 | C | Team Karabell |