"I got ahead of him and I made a really bad pitch," Matz said. "That's what it boils down to."
Senzatela hit a tying, two-run single that ended a year-long 0-for-44 slide at the plate, and Story followed three pitches later with a three-run homer to cap a six-run fourth inning. The Colorado Rockies beat the Mets 9-4 Monday night to drop New York five games back for the second NL wild card with 12 games to play.
"We can't really think about that too much," Matz said. "We've been in a hole in the season before, and we've got to go and play our best baseball and let the standings take care of themselves."
Brandon Nimmo, batting leadoff for the first time since May 17, opened the game with a home run off Senzatela (10-10). Starting their last road trip of the regular season, the Mets built a 4-1 lead on Jeff McNeil's two-run homer in the third that stopped an 0-for-13 slump and Amed Rosario's RBI double in the fourth.
Matz, who allowed Ian Desmond's second-inning homer, needed 42 pitches to get through the fourth and dropped to 0-2 with a 10.15 ERA in three starts at Coors Field.
No. 8 hitter Drew Butera walked to bring up Senzatela, who had not gotten a hit since a two-run single off San Francisco's Dereck Rodriguez on Sept. 16 last year. With the count 1-2, Senzatela lined a sinker into left field.
"Just looking for something to hit, get a base hit," Senzatela said.
Story followed with a drive into the left-field seats off Matz (10-9), who allowed seven runs, six hits and two walks in four innings.
"A pitch out over the plate and he got a base hit," Mets manager Mickey Callaway said. "That kind of opened up the floodgates.
Senzatela gave up four runs and eight hits in six innings.
"I felt really good with the breaking ball today," he said.
Desmond made a nice leaping catch near the top of the left-field wall against Nimmo in the fifth.
Mets rookie Pete Alonso ended a career-worst 0-for-21 slump with a fourth-inning single.
Mets: RHP Robert Gsellman (right tricep tightness) could return before the end of the regular season, Callaway said. ... Callaway said INF Dominic Smith (right shoulder) is in Florida and will begin baseball activities soon.
Rockies: LHP Kyle Freeland (left groin strain) is scheduled to throw a simulated game on Tuesday. Freeland, out since Aug. 21, hopes to return this season.
Colorado has allowed 16 leadoff homers, tying the major league record set by the 2017 Seattle Mariners, according to the Elias Sports Bureau.
HITTING THE WALL
Mets LF J.D. Davis ran into the wall after snaring Story's drive in the eighth inning. He lay on the ground and was looked at by a trainer but stayed in the game.
Davis was surprised to see Alonso run over from first base to check on him.
I asked him, `What are you doing out here?" Davis said. "And he said, `I've got to check out the Sun Bear.' I said, `You're ridiculous, go back to first.' Sun Bear, I guess that's his new nickname for me."
More AP MLB: https://apnews.com/MLB and https://twitter.com/AP-Sports
Cubs set to interview Gabe Kapler, Astros coach Joe Espada
Astros bench coach Joe Espada is expected to interview with the Cubs Monday, and Gabe Kapler will also talk to the team about the manager's job.
Scouting top prospects in the AFL and instructional league
Who impressed and who didn't? Check out the latest reports on some of the top prospects in baseball, including Astros righty Forrest Whitley.
Ranking MLB playoffs' best remaining starting pitchers
Verlander, Strasburg, Scherzer, Tanaka, Flaherty and, yes, Gerrit Cole. These playoffs have had some great starting pitching. We rank the best of the best.
MLB Playoffs Daily: Cardinals' bats need to wake up against Nationals
The St. Louis offense has been a no-show so far in the NLCS, and things won't get any easier against Stephen Strasburg in Game 3.
First comes the NLDS, then comes ... a baby? Inside Daniel Hudson's life-altering weekend
Daniel Hudson's decision to skip NLCS Game 1 to be with his wife as she gave birth to their daughter made headlines. But for him, it was never really a choice.
For Aaron Boone and Yankees, it's go bold or go home in ALCS
New York's manager has to be aggressive, with a balancing act that might burn him at times but is his team's best shot at beating the Astros.