A 1-1 draw with South Korea in a dramatic end to the group stage Thursday left Germany in third place in Group H behind Colombia and Morocco. In the end, it was Morocco who inflicted the damage with an unexpected win over Colombia in a game being played at the same time but on the other side of the Australian continent.
When the final whistle blew, the German players lingered on the field in a state of shock.
"We are all very speechless," German midfielder Lena Oberdorf said. "Things didn't quite click. We didn't really show the combination we can show and we can play."
It was a surprising 2-1 loss to Colombia this past Sunday that left Germany in the position of needing to win their group stage finale to guarantee they advanced to the knockout round.
The two-time champions had reached the quarterfinals or better at every previous edition of the global women's tournament. But when Morocco took a 1-0 lead over Colombia, it was suddenly make-or-break time and a 1-1 draw simply wouldn't be enough.
Even then, coach Martina Voss-Tecklenburg elected to wait to tell the players that another goal was essential.
"We heard at about 85 minutes," German goalkeeper Merle Frohms said. "Our coach didn't want to make us nervous by telling us at half-time."
Germany pushed for a late winner and went so close that Alexandra Popp's header hit the crossbar, but didn't find the back of the net.
Despite all their past credentials, the Germans are now painfully aware that the expanded 32-team draw and greater investment in the wider women's game makes progressing at the World Cup a more difficult proposition.
"It was just not enough for that tournament," Oberdorf said. "In women's football, the game is growing and it's not easy to come to the round of 16. That's clear."
Popp is still one of the stars of the international game, and her tally of four goals was a bright spot for Germany at the tournament. She finished the group stage tied for the most goals with Japan's Hinata Miyazawa.
"We need some time to process what has happened and to be able to find some confidence again," Popp said. "At this stage, we know that our squad is good, but we were not good enough in these last two games."
Voss-Tecklenburg took responsibility for the loss but didn't explain what went wrong for Germany.
"We need to work out how we move into the future," Voss-Tecklenburg said. "We have to face up to the fact that this was a historically bad result."