MP says Wales club system is in 'crisis'
December 19, 2013
Pontypridd MP and shadow secretary of state for Wales Owen Smith has claimed the club game in the country is in "crisis" and is "failing".
The Pontypridd MP has called for a "root and branch" review of the Welsh game, pleading with the Welsh Rugby Union and bosses at the four regions to put their political posturing aside. Regional Rugby Wales, the body that represents provincial sides Cardiff Blues, Scarlets, Ospreys and the Newport-Gwent Dragons, is preparing to take the WRU to court.
The regions have written to Welsh MPs and the Welsh Assembly to garner support for their potential court battle with the WRU. Smith admits he is an advocate of change, but called on all parties to approach the issues in boardrooms not law courts.
Smith said: "Even though Wales has enjoyed great success at international level in recent years, the club game has been in permanent crisis since the creation of the regional clubs.
"Our game is failing because fans have never truly warmed to the regional concept and want a game based on traditional club identities and the centuries of fraternal rivalry that exists between them.
"In many parts of our rugby heartlands fans, players and the volunteers who are the backbones of our rugby clubs feel totally alienated from the elite, professional game."
Criticising both clubs and union for muscle-flexing in the latest round of talks aimed at amending existing league structures, Smith called for an end to the "phoney confections" of the regions, and the restoration of traditional clubs tied to singular towns and cities.
Smith added: "This latest crisis is nothing more than a power struggle between the clubs and the union for control of the game's principal assets, money and the players that generate it.
"Whoever wins that battle, the wider game will be the loser in the long term.
"What we need is root and branch reform, a return to a structure built on our traditional clubs, whose identities will never be eroded by the phoney confections of the Dragons, Blues and Ospreys, and an end to the closed shop which says only those four clubs can ever aspire to play at the top level of the game."
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
Amir Khan won't be taking up Floyd Mayweather's challenge to fight Adrien Broner, his trainer Virgil Hunter has confirmed
British sprinters Dwain Chambers and Richard Kilty won their 60m heats to progress to Saturday's semi-finals at the World Indoor Championships in Sopot
Leyton Hewitt moved within one victory of becoming the third active ATP Tour player to win 600 matches after seeing off fellow Australian Matthew Ebden 7-6(2) 3-6 6-3 in the first round at Indian Wells
Chris Gayle has suggested England are substantially weaker without Kevin Pietersen and believes terminating his contract was "disrespectful"
Maria Sharapova believes men's grand slam matches should be played over three sets instead of five to make them more "exciting"
With just two rounds left in the 2014 championship, the intensity cranks up a notch at Twickenham. Tom Hamilton previews the weekend's action
Only Chelsea and Liverpool can win the Premier League this season, despite Jose Mourinho's claims
Australian Rugby Union officials in recent times have "lacked authority" when negotiating with New Zealand and South Africa, and they need to show "more backbone" when pushing national causes, Greg Growden reports
Tottenham have not won a game at Stamford Bridge against Chelsea since 1990, but there revival under Tim Sherwood could see them upset the odds in this London derby
Last year's thrashing at the hands of Wales was not the first time England have fallen to their rivals. Scrum Sevens looks at whether they have bounced back the following year
Cristiano Ronaldo has played down his latest record, claiming landmarks come naturally to him
Eden Hazard believes he can surpass Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi to be the best player in the world - but knows he needs to be twice the player he is at the moment to achieve his goal
Samir Nasri insists Arsene Wenger is a "magician" and believes criticism of his former manager about his lack of trophies is unfair
Mesut Ozil continued to face criticism as he was jeered by a section of Germany fans during his nation's 1-0 friendly win over Chile in Stuttgart
David Moyes was in attendance for France's 2-0 friendly win against the Netherlands in Paris on Wednesday to scout Antoine Griezmann and Paul Pogba as he considers how to rebuild his Manchester United squad
Join Gareth Davies, Ben Blackmore and Chris Park each week for the latest news, views and debate from the UFC
Once prone to putting his head down and looking the other way when walking past fans on the street, Andy Murray is finding lots of reasons to look them in the eye
'I'm glad that Vasyl Lomachenko is a pro and I'm also glad that he lost on Saturday,' writes ESPN's resident boxing expert Steve Bunce
The waiting is finally over after it was announced that 82-year-old Nick Bollettieri will be enshrined in the International Tennis Hall of Fame later this summer