Time for Super Rugby to ditch South Africa?
April 16, 2014
Australian sides pose at the start of the season ... will a time come when they just play more locally? © SANZAR
Former All Black Andrew Mehrtens has said Australia and New Zealand should withdraw from Super Rugby and restrict future tournaments between themselves.
With proposals to expand the competition to include another South African franchise as well as teams from Argentina, Mehrtens wrote in his stuff.co.nz column that more localised events were the way forward.
"I can't help thinking we might have lost a little interest in playing South African teams, and that ultimately the future of this competition might be more localised round time zones," he said. "The provincial championship still has a pretty strong following, and if you're looking at what Australia and New Zealand needs, maybe it's that parochialism, that tribalism which is very important."
Given Australian rugby is in a deep financial hole, Mehrtens' comments will not be unwelcome reading to many involved in the game there. "The logistics of involving South Africa are problematic - the travel and time difference - and maybe it would be better for all concerned just to play within our time zone."
With the South African government again pushing the controversial move towards a forced reintroduction of racial quotas in sport, events could force a change anyway. Under IRB regulations, such a system would be classified as racial discrimination and could lead to South Africa being suspended from competition.
Mehrtens said the future was elsewhere. "[We could] include teams from the Pacific Islands and Japan. Maybe there could still be post-season involvement with South Africa, but their natural alignment is more with the UK and Europe, in the same time zone. You might have 20 teams in our time-zone - eight or so from New Zealand, maybe six in Australia and the rest from the islands and Japan."
He said that New Zealand's geographical isolation meant it needed mutually beneficial and closer links with Australia. "It's a biggish economy and there's a lot of money to be tapped into if it's done well.
"Australia has a lot of potential for growth, especially with broadcasting revenue, and New Zealand needs to recognise this. At the moment rugby is the poor cousin of the winter codes but that could easily change."
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
Communication error please reload the page.
Manchester United target Mats Hummels is considering his Borussia Dortmund future
Three-time world champion Niki Lauda says Sebastian Vettel's victory in Malaysia was good for Formula One and the German driver's own image after the reputation he built between 2010 and 2013
Amir Khan believes the time is not right for a Battle of Britain with Kell Brook for the IBF world welterweight title as the reigning champion is virtually unknown in the United States
Mercedes boss Toto Wolff says Sebastian Vettel's win for Ferrari in Malaysia has set alarm bells ringing for the reigning world champion
Wayne Rooney believes England are at last starting to strike fear into opponents. The Three Lions were all too easily exposed during a disappointing summer in Brazil last year
Concussion, relegation and the mother of all surprises - it's the Monday Maul.
Queensland are worth watching again, even if victory over the Lions would have papered over cracks, because Quade Cooper is back in the No.10 jersey, Greg Growden writes
In a exciting return from injury, Quade Cooper thrilled fans to become Player of the Round, while a new star now leads the medal tally
The Hurricanes have always been a franchise rich on talent, but something was always awry; not any more as they look the real deal Sam Bruce writes
Six months after being victim of a machete attack that left him fearing for his life, Kell Brook dished out a vicious attack of his own in his a first world title defence
Kell Brook is not waiting for Amir Khan to make up his mind about fighting him and hopes to face either Mexican Juan Manuel Marquez or American Brandon Rios this summer
Patrick Kluivert has revealed he did not follow Louis van Gaal to Manchester United as his No.2 last summer as he was holding out for a managerial role instead
Luis Suarez received a rapturous reception as he made his first return to Anfield since joining Barcelona, playing the second half of a charity game between sides captained by Steven Gerrard and Jamie Carragher
Danny Welbeck believes signing for Arsenal has helped him to improve his international form for England
Rory McIlroy walked off at the Honda Classic. What next for the Northern Irishman?
Join Steve Bunce and Barry Jones each week for the latest news, views and debate from the boxing world.
Who has driven in the most GPs before taking pole position?
Unbeaten heavyweight Dillian Whyte, 28, (14-0, 11 KOs) tells ESPN where his rivalry with Anthony Joshua stems from and outlines the plan for his career this year after returning from a doping ban in November