Leading referees reprimanded for blunder
March 20, 2014
Stuart Berry blows for time last weekend © Getty Images
Leading referees Stuart Berry and Johan Greeff have been reprimanded for an error which cost the Blues a Super Rugby victory over the Lions in Johannesburg last weekend, but the South African officials will still officiate in the Lions' home game against Queensland Reds on Saturday.
On-field referee Berry and television match official Greeff combined to award a second-half try to the Lions in their 39-36 win even though replays showed that centre Deon van Rensburg had lost the ball forward in a tackle from winger Charles Piutau.
SANZAR referees' boss Lyndon Bray said Greeff, under prompting from Berry, was wrong to rule that Piutau had stripped the ball, which was then pounced on by Lions fullback Coenie van Wyk. "The onus is on the ball carrier to maintain possession while being tackled," he said. "Therefore, this should have been ruled as a knock-on and subsequently, no try.
Blues coach Sir John Kirwan, who contested a number of decisions from the game, his team's third loss, said after the match that the try had proved decisive as it had halted his side's momentum as they fought back from their 17-0 half-time deficit.
Kirwan said on Thursday that Bray's statement represented "a step in the right direction … we're in the industry of accountability so I thought it was great of him to come out and say that they got something wrong, because that means they're working hard on getting a lot right. It's a positive for us".
Berry and Greeff will take the same respective referee and TMO roles in the Lions' match against Queensland.
The mistake was the second going against the Blues in the space of a fortnight. Bray said a try awarded to the Bulls in their win over the Blues at Loftus Versfeld should also have been disallowed. "That's a very good example of where a player quite clearly moves his body in order to be able to place the ball," he said. "So ultimately, yes, that should have been no try."
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd.
Communication error please reload the page.
Ireland's Kevin Phelan carried on from where he left off last week by carding an opening 67 to claim a share of the lead in the Africa Open at East London Golf Club
Newcastle United striker Papiss Cisse and Manchester United's Jonny Evans have both been charged by the FA for allegedly spitting at each other
Manchester United manager Louis van Gaal has reacted angrily to suggestions his relationship with assistant Ryan Giggs has deteriorated
Formula One will have new safety cars and medical cars in 2015 in the form of a Mercedes-AMG GT S and C63 S
Louis van Gaal has reiterated his desire to lead Manchester United back into the Champions League and, while admitting winning the FA Cup would be "fantastic", insisted the club's priority remains to finish in the top four
Wayne Rooney loves a goal against Arsenal, and you can get him at 25/1 with Bet365 to score in a 1-0 for Manchester United on Monday
After Nemanja Matic twisted his ankle celebrating Chelsea's League Cup win, ESPN runs down some of the game's most ludicrous injuries
How appetising do 160g of protein, 100g of carbs and 60g of fats sound? Paul Butler takes Inside Boxing through his scientifically-managed eating habits
Andre Agassi said this week that Andy Murray plays at his best when he's under pressure - and he will no doubt thrive on what will be an emotional Scotland homecoming when Great Britain take on the United States in the Davis Cup
Is there still a rugby league county championship?
Amir Khan is unlikely to face Kell Brook this summer as he looks to negotiate a fight with Miguel Cotto in America
Louis van Gaal wants his Manchester United players to cut out the backpasses to David De Gea as frustrations mount among supporters over his side's unadventurous approach this season
Brendan Rodgers admits Liverpool's defeat at Crystal Palace in November left him fearing for his job at Anfield
Andre Ward has warned Carl Froch that he will be calling all of the shots over their proposed title unification bout
Emre Can sees his long-term future at Liverpool as a midfielder, but insists he will never be the new Steven Gerrard
Eight years ago, Steve Bunce was offered the chance of buying a 'share' in Tyson Fury, and it would have been a shrewd investment if he had the money
He may try and play down his obsession with his appearance, but Cristiano Ronaldo has apparently been sending a personal stylist to regularly brush up his waxwork model
Who was the 100th man to win a world championship Grand Prix?
Paul Butler tells Inside Boxing he turned down the chance of a trial with Liverpool in order to focus on boxing - and it was the right choice
Some of the best fighters to ever glove up have plied their trade in the Octagon - now ESPN list the 10 best who have fought under the UFC banner