We introduce the Greg Growden Medal
February 21, 2014
The Growden Medal will recognise Australia's best and most consistent player © Scrum.com
The Greg Growden Medal recognises Australia's best and most consistent Super Rugby players with a revolutionary weighted points system that rewards proper performance like no other.
The traditional 3-2-1 award voting system can be misleading. Judges some weeks can easily select three, four, five players worthy of man-of-the-match status or the next best. Other weeks, there are no players really worthy of a vote but still someone gets three points, two points, one, even when they don't deserve it.
This leads to an imbalance.
Often, outstanding performances are overlooked, including those of players who make an enormous impact off the bench late in the game while fair-to-middling efforts receive points that are not warranted; at the very least, many such performances aren't given they due recognition.
But the Greg Growden Medal is different. As you might expect given the man for whom the award is named: the Greg Growden Medal is focused like many others awards on the recognition of Australia's best and most consistent Super Rugby players, but, like no other, its judgment involves a weighted points system that rewards proper performance.
In every Super Rugby game involving an Australian team, as many as five players from each Australian province can receive points up to 10. So a man-of-the-match performance may warrant anything from 10 out of 10 down to a few points: it depends on the quality of the performance, how much impact the player had on the game, the calibre of the match, and the opposition. There may even be several Australian players in a single game who receive the same number of points as the supposed man of the match. And if no-one plays well, no points will be allocated.
So in Australian derbies, anywhere between 0 and 10 players can receive points; up to five per team. (And no, we are not allocating points to New Zealand and South African provincial players; this award is about finding the Australian provinces' best.) We will use the same system later in the year, when we determine the 2014 Wallabies Player of the Year.
Each week, we will provide an overall leaderboard, and a list of the highest-ranked players for each province - so you'll know exactly who has and hasn't been performing.
Many weeks, in the eyes of some folk, we will get it wrong. But we aim to get it right. No matter what, the weekly column will be here to prompt vigorous comment, argument, complaints, tantrums, and someone to blame if you believe your province or a certain player is being victimised.
Join us each week to see Greg's verdict on the Australian players who are / are not performing. We'll respond to all comment and reasoned discussion either in comments at the foot of the story, or on Twitter using the hashtag #GregGrowdenMedal.
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
Communication error please reload the page.
Swansea striker Bafetimbi Gomis collapsed six minutes into Wednesday's match at Tottenham and was carried off the field on a stretcher
Alex Dreyfus, CEO of the Global Poker Index, envisioned the day when he purchased the European Poker Awards two years ago. While the Europeans have had an annual awards celebration for over a decade, America has never seen a poker awards experience before
Unbeaten heavyweight Anthony Joshua has hinted at a potential fight with American veteran Tony Thompson
The Manor Marussia F1 team has confirmed it will take part in the Australian Grand Prix in less than two weeks after naming Stephen Fitzpatrick as the man behind its financial revival
Scotland head coach Vern Cotter has been forced to recall three players from club duty in order to cover player injuries
Join Steve Bunce and Barry Jones each week for the latest news, views and debate from the boxing world.
Head injuries are not a trivial matter in sport - especially in one which will never fully eliminate the danger posed to its drivers
Aston Villa manager Tim Sherwood was so delighted with his side's last-gasp win over West Brom that he said the three points were better than his wife winning the Euro Millions jackpot
He may try and play down his obsession with his appearance, but Cristiano Ronaldo has apparently been sending a personal stylist to regularly brush up his waxwork model
Paul Butler tells Inside Boxing he turned down the chance of a trial with Liverpool in order to focus on boxing - and it was the right choice
Rafael Benitez has raised concerns about the long-term fitness of Chelsea captain John Terry after revealing the defender is trapped in "a vicious circle" regarding his persistent knee injury
John Terry says he is fighting for his family's future but has pledged never to play for another club when his time at Chelsea comes to an end
Carl Froch has challenged Andre Ward to step into enemy territory at Nottingham Forest's City Ground for their proposed super-middleweight title unification bout
Louis van Gaal has come to the defence of Angel Di Maria after the midfielder's Manchester United career reached a new low when he was taken off at half-time in Saturday's 2-0 win over Sunderland
Crystal Palace midfielder Mile Jedinak has been charged with violent conduct for elbowing West Ham's Diafra Sakho, the Football Association has announced
Eight years ago, Steve Bunce was offered the chance of buying a 'share' in Tyson Fury, and it would have been a shrewd investment if he had the money
After enduring a tricky start to his Manchester United career, perhaps it is fair that Marcos Rojo celebrated so boisterously as he watched his first professional club Estudiantes beat fierce rivals Gimnasia
The idea of Chelsea squeezing in a quick 20-minute Wembley celebration before getting back to work is both admirable and typically soulless, writes Alan Tyers
A basketball match between Bilbao Basket and Laboral Kutxa Baskonia in the Spanish ACB League was marred by a brawl that erupted in the closing stages of the game
Former Oasis guitarist Noel Gallagher marked his return to football punditry by coining a new name for Liverpool manager Brendan Rodgers