ESPN SCRUM

/ South Africa

/ News

South Africa
South Africa quota plans to be referred to IRB
ESPN Staff
June 24, 2014
Jean de Villiers receives the trophy from sports minister Fikile Mbalula, South Africa v Samoa, Pretoria, June 22, 2013
Fikile Mbalula had demanded the immediate implementation of proposals which would have meant all teams had to have at least 60% black or coloured players © Getty Images
Enlarge

The ongoing issues over quotas in South African rugby has again surfaced with a report that a complaint is being filed with the IRB over plans by the government to re-introduce such a system.

In April, Fikile Mbalula, the country's sports minister, had demanded the immediate implementation of proposals which would have meant all teams had to have at least 60% black or coloured players. He said any organisation refusing to fall into line would have all central funding withdrawn and could be prevented from taking part in international competitions. He subsequently delayed the implementation after meeting representatives of various sporting groups.

On Monday, Beeld carried a report that SARU president Oregan Hoskins had sent a message to Springbok coach Heyneke Meyer asking for a greater representation of blacks in the national team.

"We need to give black players, specifically 'African blacks', more chances in the team," Hoskins told the newspaper. "I spoke to the coach and he agreed, the time is right for this. I believe we will already see a change or two against Scotland this coming weekend."

Now civil rights organisation AfriForum is taking the matter to the IRB, arguing the governing body's own rules prohibit racial discrimination and political interference in rugby.

AfriForum claims to represent the discrimination of minorities in South Africa with "a specific focus on the rights of Afrikaners as a community living on the southern tip of the continent".

"SARU's instruction to the Springbok coach is a crude form of racial discrimination," AfriForum chief executive Kallie Kriel said. "[It's] an indication that SARU has surrendered to the quota threats of Mbalula.

"A racial quota system disadvantages all talented players of all races. White players are disadvantaged because they are excluded from participation based on their race and the validity of the inclusion of black players in teams is by default suspect."

He said the government and SARU "should address their own failure to develop young talent at school level with development programmes rather than playing the numbers game in a top-down manipulation of the sport".

AfriForum's would also look into the possibility of opening a case with the International Court for Arbitration in Sport.

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Football

  • Cricket

  • Rugby

    • Days
    • Hrs
    • Mins
    • Secs

    F1 - Australian GP

  • OtherLive >>

    Golf - Africa Open
    Golf - WGC-Cadillac Championship
    Darts - UK Open finals
    Tennis - Davis Cup first round
    Boxing - Shayne Singleton v Sam Eggington; Luke Campbell v Gary Sykes
  • Latest
  • Most Viewed
  • News
  • Features
  • Rugby

    Meat leaves Honey Badger hungry for more

    Having "bagged a bit of meat" with just his second touch back in Super Rugby, Nick Cummins says he's keen to get himself placed in Michael Cheika's World Cup squad

  • Boxing

    Butler suffers knockout defeat to champion Tete

    Paul Butler failed his quest to become a two-weight world champion within a year after he suffered an eighth-round knockout at the hands of Zolani Tete on Friday

  • Golf

    Erratic McIlroy throws club into lake at Doral

    World No.1 Rory McIlroy apologised for throwing his three iron into a water hazard after more erratic play in the second round of the WGC-Cadillac Championship on Friday

  • Darts

    Defending champion Lewis among UK Open casualties

    Defending champion Adrian Lewis and PDC world champion Gary Anderson were both knocked out of the UK Open at the third round stage in Minehead on Friday

  • Rugby

    Glasgow sweep Zebre aside to go top

    Glasgow hammer bottom side Zebre to go top of the Guiness PRO12 as Cardiff Blues secure a last-gasp victory at home to Connacht in Friday's evening fixtures

  • Formula One

    Pointless drivers

    Where does Anthony Davidson's record of 24 Grands Prix without a point rank him?

  • Formula 1

    'I'm more than just a pay driver' - Ericsson

    ESPN talks to Marcus Ericsson about the "pay driver" label, aiming for his first career points and what life was really like as a rookie during Caterham's chaotic final season

  • Football

    Ronaldo and co. fear nutmegs at Real Madrid, says Bale

    Gareth Bale says he has to be sharp in training or the other Real Madrid galacticos will quickly be on his case

  • Formula 1

    Grand Prix Trust: Taking care of the carers

    Amid the glitz and glamour of modern grand prix racing it can be all too easy to forget about the men and women that keep the wheels turning. The Grand Prix Trust makes sure that's not the case

  • Football

    Evans-Cisse spitting spat exposes football's glaring flaws

    A spitting contest. Just what football needs to improve its reputation. You can always rely on football to stoop that little bit lower than you expected. Papiss Cisse of Newcastle United and Jonny Evans of Manchester United, who later protested his innoce

  • News
  • Features
Sponsored Links
Make Huge Income from your Home
Download your Free Guide And Learn How To Increase Your Monthly Income