South African board accused of racial discrimination
December 3, 2013
The Springboks celebrate beating South Africa in September ... but this predominantly white line-up would not be tolerated at domestic level © Getty Images
The South African board (SARU) has been warned that proposals to implement racial quotas in its Vodacom Cup would be a violation of the IRB's ban on racial discrimination.
SARU was advised in writing by AfriForum, a Civil rights organisation, that the Olympic Charter, with which rugby has to follow as it is now an Olympic sport, explicitly prohibits racial discrimination.
Under new rules, teams will be forced to field seven players of colour in their 22-man squads, with at least five players in the starting team. At least two of the seven will also have to be among the forwards.
"AfriForum is doing everything in its power to convince SARU to comply with the rules of the IRB and abandon the quota system," explained Kallie Kriel, the organisation's chief executive. "Rugby unions should focus on development programmes instead of discriminating against certain players on the basis of race.
"A quota system, however, does nothing to develop new players. Institutions simply import existing black players in order to comply with the quota requirements."
Kriel said that the quota system actually penalised black players as it raised questions over the validity of their selection and could lead to claims they had not been picked on ability alone.
He went on to say that the SARU and the government were trying to paper over their failure to develop young black talent.
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
Communication error please reload the page.
Whether Scott Quigg was going to face Nehomar Cermeno or late replacement Tshifhiwa Munyai, he said his fans will see the very best from him
UFC president Dana White would like to see veteran heavyweight Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira retire following a knockout loss to Roy Nelson last week
Brendan Rodgers believes Manchester City's draw with Sunderland provides a stark warning for his Liverpool side that they have no room for complacency in the title race
Laura Robson has been ruled out of the French Open and Wimbledon after opting to undergo surgery on her injured left wrist
Former Manchester City manager Roberto Mancini believes that Samir Nasri is throwing away his chance at becoming a world-class player
Thiago Alves feels like he's built up credit with whatever forces control injuries in mixed martial arts. After four surgeries in the last two years, he's paid up for a while
Martin Gillingham looks ahead to what he believes is the most remarkable ever climax to the league phase of the Top 14
The Inside Line looks at the reasons why the Shanghai experience gets an unfair review every season from many on F1's travelling circus
With just two rounds left in the regular season, we look at the prospects of the teams taking part in the Championship play-offs
The ARU's appalling handling of Israel Folau's throat injury may well see the star return to rugby league, writes Greg Growden
Manchester United are edging closer to a £30 million deal for Southampton left-back Luke Shaw, which would see them fend off Premier League rivals Chelsea for the youngster's signature
Manchester United striker Wayne Rooney and Mercedes F1 driver Lewis Hamilton were among the world's top 25 highest paid athletes over the last year
Chelsea are moving closer to a deal for long-time target Diego Costa, which could see the striker become the club's joint-highest paid player alongside Eden Hazard
Arsene Wenger has praised West Ham winger Matt Jarvis for not going to ground to win a penalty during Arsenal's 3-1 win at the Emirates on Tuesday - but Sam Allardyce insisted his player had been too honest
Amir Khan's chances of securing a lucrative fight with Floyd Mayweather Jr have notably improved after the Bolton fighter confirmed he had signed with the American's boxing advisor Al Haymon
I am arguing with my friend, who thinks Vitali Klitschko is still a world champion - I thought he had retired. Who's right?
Sergio Perez finished third at the Bahrain Grand Prix. Have Force India ever had a finish on the podium before?
Stephen A. Smith and Skip Bayless discuss the correlation between Tiger Woods' success and golf ratings and debate if he is the most important athlete to his sport
Even at the age of 49, Bernard Hopkins - who faces Beibut Shumenov in his 32nd world title fight in Washington on Saturday - remains a dedicated student of boxing, writes Steve Bunce
After each round of Premier League fixtures, ESPN FC brings you its Team of the Weekend. Our panel of experts carefully selects 11 star performers, along with a manager