ESPN SCRUM

/ News

TMO debate
Video refs 'spoiling the game'
ESPN Staff
May 9, 2014
Tim Wigglesworth goes to the TMO for a decision, Gloucester v Bath, Aviva Premiership,  Kingsholm Stadium, April 12, 2014
Here we go again ... Tim Wigglesworth goes to the TMO for a decision during the recent Premiership match between Gloucester and Bath © Getty Images
Enlarge

Former England player turned pundit Austin Healey has joined in the debate about the increasing use of the TMO, stating that since the introduction of the TV official the referee's decision-making ability has been diluted.

Writing in the Daily Telegraph, he said: "What we have seen recently is that the practice of referees and touch judges working in tandem has actually faltered. And it is beginning to spoil the game.

"My main argument against the TMO is that if we want constantly to improve referees, and we need to, the last thing we want is for them to be questioning themselves. What the TMO gives them is hindsight - a second chance. That is great after a game, but not during."

Echoing Richard Cockerill's comments a day before, he said that matches were now stretching to over 95 minutes because of increasing referrals.

"The overall effect of the TMO is not making the game better, which is what these innovations are meant to achieve. It is not making it a better spectacle and it is certainly not making the referees better. If we are not careful, supporters are going to turn away from the sport."

He said that use of the TMO should be limited to tries."The system is being overused and it is protecting referees and preventing them from taking full responsibility. There is nothing wrong in sport with the referee being wrong. Actually, there is no such thing as the referee being wrong. He is always right.

"Let us allow the referee to make more decisions. That is what he is there for. After all, he is the sole arbiter of what happens on the ball. So, let him take greater responsibility. He might make some wrong decisions, but that is sport."

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Latest
  • Most Viewed
  • News
  • Features
  • Rugby

    Chiefs survive stern challenge despite ill-discipline

    The Chiefs beat the Cheetahs in Hamilton to regain winning form, but only after they had conceded 12 penalties and received two yellow cards in the first half

  • Formula 1

    Ecclestone frustrated and disappointed with F1

    Bernie Ecclestone says Formula One needs to be a lot better at facing its problems and admits he is disappointed in the sport

  • Rugby

    Saints play down George North injury fears

    Northampton Saints director of rugby Jim Mallinder said George North was "OK now" after the winger was carried off the pitch on a stretcher following a blow to the head

  • Rugby

    Reds can still make rugby finals: Graham

    After another disastrous night out, the Reds fell to a one-point loss to the Lions, but Reds coach Richard Graham still believes the Reds have a chance to make the finals

  • Football

    Injured duo Welbeck and Sterling to miss Italy friendly

    England manager Roy Hodgson confirmed that Arsenal striker Danny Welbeck will miss Tuesday's international friendly against Italy with injury, while Liverpool winger Raheem Sterling will also be excused from the game in Turin

  • Formula One

    Tough at the top

    Who has driven in the most GPs before taking pole position?

  • Formula 1

    F1 cost cutting: Not putting money where the mouth is

    Mudslinging and an agreement on something that will never happen, it's all in a day's work for a Formula One boss, as Maurice Hamilton explains...

  • Rugby

    Unsavoury sledging did not end with Potgieter

    Fallout continues from the NSW-Brumbies derby, with one Tahs forward - not Potgieter - surprised by other unsavoury comments during the game, Greg Growden reports

  • Rugby

    Super Rugby preview, team news, line-ups: Round 7

    Greg Growden previews Super Rugby round 7. We've also got key stats, team news and all the line-ups to inform your ESPN Footytips Super Rugby picks

  • Formula 1

    Storm clouds gather in Malaysia

    Will Mercedes dominate again? Can anybody catch up with the help of a rainstorm? And will the Red Bull/Renault relationship tear itself apart? All those questions and more will be answered at this weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix

  • News
  • Features

Sponsored Links

Make Huge Income from your Home
Download your Free Guide And Learn How To Increase Your Monthly Income