RFU's 'no winners' policy criticised
January 27, 2014
There are fears the new policy could have a detrimental effect on young players © Getty Images
The Rugby Football Union's (RFU) policy of removing the possibility of winning from children's 'mini rugby' games has drawn criticism from prominent rugby clubs in Surrey, where it is first being introduced.
The RFU's new rules not only state that games of 'mini rugby', a format of the game in the six to 11 age group, must have no winner, but that teams must be of 'mixed ability', and can be weakened mid-game if one side is ahead in the scoreline too heavily. Prominent rugby clubs Esher and Rosslyn Park have already announced their withdrawal from the Surrey Tournament - where the rules will be debuted.
Teams who fail to follow the new guidelines will see their club's age-group sides thrown out of the tournament and face further disciplinary action. The round-robin system, which is split into 'A', 'B' or 'C' development medals to pit children of similar standards against each other, is being scrapped.
Former England international and Esher board member Simon Halliday has been one of the most vocal critics.
He wrote in the Financial Times: "We are appalled and have withdrawn from all Surrey rugby competition. In sport there are winners and losers. As long as you don't demean the loser, it's straightforward."
With a home World Cup on the horizon the RFU is keen to increase the sport's popularity, and feel the new policy will keep children playing the sport who would otherwise be put off by its competitive nature.
"The tournaments will still have matches which are won or lost but this is about removing the 'win-at-all-costs mentality' which is creeping into the game," said the RFU's development director Steve Grainger.
"That can lead to coaches not giving all players a game, just choosing their best players to try to win the tournament, and that will drive kids out of the sport."
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
Communication error please reload the page.
Real Madrid left-back Fabio Coentrao says he would be very interested in a move to Manchester United next season
Manchester United have taken non-league sensation Sam Grimshaw on trial, sources have told ESPN
Rugby league legend Kevin Sinfield has opted to cross codes to union and has signed for Yorkshire Carnegie
Kimi Raikkonen says Ferrari still has work to do to be consistently competitive with Mercedes but is confident it has taken a big chunk out of Mercedes lead following Sebastian Vettel's victory in Malaysia
Ulster are on the verge of completing the signing of All Blacks winger Charles Piutau
The Hurricanes have always been a franchise rich on talent, but something was always awry; not any more as they look the real deal Sam Bruce writes
Could the ongoing problems with the interpretation of the breakdown and rolling maul be solved with a simplification of the lawbook? Scrum5 discusses
Maurice Hamilton looks through the reaction of the British press to Sebastian Vettel and Ferrari returning to winning ways at the Malaysian Grand Prix
Concussion, relegation and the mother of all surprises - it's the Monday Maul.
Luis Suarez graced the Anfield turf again on Sunday and vowed that if he ever returned to England, it would only be to play for Liverpool
Arsenal right-back Hector Bellerin has said he is unsure if he would have made the grade if he had stayed at Barcelona and is pleased to have been given a chance by Arsene Wenger
Six months after being victim of a machete attack that left him fearing for his life, Kell Brook dished out a vicious attack of his own in his a first world title defence
Amir Khan believes the time is not right for a Battle of Britain with Kell Brook for the IBF world welterweight title as the reigning champion is virtually unknown in the United States
Manchester United target Mats Hummels is considering his Borussia Dortmund future
Rory McIlroy walked off at the Honda Classic. What next for the Northern Irishman?
Who has driven in the most GPs before taking pole position?
After a 10-year break in the fixture, England and Italy have faced each other three times in as many seasons, with one win each and a draw
Join Steve Bunce and Barry Jones each week for the latest news, views and debate from the boxing world.
Some of the best fighters to ever glove up have plied their trade in the Octagon - now ESPN list the 10 best who have fought under the UFC banner