ESPN SCRUM

/ News

News
Rugby is becoming 'a sport for freaks'
ESPN Staff
November 25, 2013
Another one bites the dust ... Francois Louw is carted off the field with a neck injury at Murrayfield © Getty Images
Enlarge

A leading surgeon has expressed his concern at the increasing number of injuries saying that rugby had become "a sport for freaks".

The most serious recent injury came the weekend before last when Italy centre Luca Morisi had his spleen removed after suffering internal injuries during a tough match against Fiji, while England hooker Dylan Hartley was left requiring treatment for a bruised lung after the All Blacks match.

"If this was boxing, we'd be starting to look at the rules," Professor John Fairclough, an orthopaedic specialist who was president of the British Sports Trauma Association, told the Rugby Paper. "I am not an expert on rugby's rules but my view is that somehow or other the game has to acknowledge that the impact at ruck and maul must be reduced.

"It alarms me totally. This is not Rollerball and yet we talk about 'breaking the line'. You can't go round people now. The game we see now is not the game as it used to be."

Fairclough said the area that really concerned him was the ruck. "You cannot just clear people out of the ruck, least of all when they're not looking. That means they're not braced for impact and that's where serious knee injuries occur. There are now so many big men laying behind the scrum that at the highest level it's become a game for those who are physically above and beyond the norm."

He said that the big increase in size of players in the last decade or so was at the root of the problems. "[It was] a sport for all shapes and sizes, then it became a sport for freaks. Look at people like Leigh Halfpenny and Shane Williams. They went from being very quick, very lithe and relatively light to having to bulk up. Look at the amount of injury that Leigh in particular has suffered.

"There is an inevitability that serious injuries will continue to rise. The human body is not meant to take that amount of force. What we're seeing here is the price of sport, not just in terms of what those in sport give up but what happens to their bodies because of it."

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Latest
  • Most Viewed
  • News
  • Features
  • Tennis

    Nadal through but Serena Williams made to wait in Florida

    Rafael Nadal eased into the third round of the Miami Open on a day when rain curtailed proceedings in Florida

  • Rugby

    Highlanders' power game too much for Stormers

    The Highlanders have hit back from last week's narrow loss to the Hurricanes with a powerful display against the Stormers at Forsyth Barr Stadium

  • Formula 1

    Allison explains Ferrari's improvement

    Ferrari technical director James Allison says his team's improvements since 2014 are split evenly between power unit and chassis, and not just down to an increase in BHP

  • Rugby

    Jevans confident RWC 2015 will deliver

    Debbie Jevans has backed the Rugby World Cup to be a huge success following her resignation as chief executive of the organising committee for the tournament

  • Football

    Arsene Wenger warns against homegrown proposal

    Arsenal manager Arsene Wenger has warned against a quota-based system being used in the Premier League believing it will dilute the quality of the division

  • Formula 1

    F1 cost cutting: Not putting money where the mouth is

    Mudslinging and an agreement on something that will never happen, it's all in a day's work for a Formula One boss, as Maurice Hamilton explains...

  • Formula One

    Tough at the top

    Who has driven in the most GPs before taking pole position?

  • Rugby

    Unsavoury sledging did not end with Potgieter

    Fallout continues from the NSW-Brumbies derby, with one Tahs forward - not Potgieter - surprised by other unsavoury comments during the game, Greg Growden reports

  • Rugby

    Super Rugby preview, team news, line-ups: Round 7

    Greg Growden previews Super Rugby round 7. We've also got key stats, team news and all the line-ups to inform your ESPN Footytips Super Rugby picks

  • Formula 1

    Storm clouds gather in Malaysia

    Will Mercedes dominate again? Can anybody catch up with the help of a rainstorm? And will the Red Bull/Renault relationship tear itself apart? All those questions and more will be answered at this weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix

  • News
  • Features

Sponsored Links

Make Huge Income from your Home
Download your Free Guide And Learn How To Increase Your Monthly Income