IRB set to continue with controversial concussion test
August 7, 2013
Australia flanker George Smith appeared to be concussed during his side's recent clash with the British & Irish Lions but was cleared to play on © Getty Images
Pitchside Suspected Concussion Assessment (PSCA)
The International Rugby Board is set to stick with its controversial concussion assessment protocol trial despite widespread concerns about its accuracy and allegations that players are cheating the test.
The sport's governing body introduced the Pitchside Suspected Concussion Assessment (PSCA) last year as part of its bid to improve player welfare but has since been accused of endangering those that play the game.
The test sees players who have suffered a suspected concussion leave the field for five minutes while the doctors determine whether they are fit enough to return to the pitch by asking the player a series of questions. If the player is suspected of having concussion he is not allowed to return to the game. Previously medics were forced to assess suspected concussion on the field with only players with blood injuries allowed to leave the field of play.
The implementation of the PSCA prompted the resignation of former IRB medical advisor Dr Barry O'Driscoll who has since gone public with his criticism of the process, accusing his former employers of 'trivialising concussion' while insisting, "There is no scientific, medical or rugby basis for the safety of this process."
The sight of Australia flanker George Smith staggering from the field following a head knock during his side's recent clash with the British & Irish Lions in Sydney, only to return to the fray a few minutes later sparked yet further criticism. Ex-Scotland international Rory Lamont labelled the PSCA as "flawed" while also revealing that players know how to cheat the tests and ensure they are cleared to play on.
Adding to alarm, Dr Willie Stewart, a consultant neuropathologist at Glasgow's Southern General Hospital, has revealed what he believes to be clear evidence related to dementia in the brain of a male in his 50s who had played rugby.
The current IRB chief medical officer Dr Martin Raftery has acknowledged the widespread criticism and vowed to add their concerns to the feedback from team doctors and their own video analysis. Changes to the PSCA are expected as a result but the trial will continue as planned.
"I read what Rory had to say and I applaud him," Rafferty told The Scotsman. "His decision to come out and speak about what is going on in the game is helpful and his message to players to stop cheating tests and ignoring head knocks is vital.
"I hope that we can use him as an ambassador because we need people in our sport to be honest if we are to make players, coaches, medics and parents aware of the seriousness of concussion and the importance of stopping players from playing with head knocks."
He added: "Having been a team doctor in those situations I have sympathy with the difficulties in diagnosing concussion in five minutes, even off the field. That is a key message to get across - concussion has been recognised as being the most complex sports injury to diagnose and there is no perfect diagnostic test or marker for clinicians to rely on. The science is lagging quite a bit behind the demands of doctors in the modern game.
"The PSCA test is not perfect, but nothing is, so, what do we do? Sit on our hands? Before PSCA medics had to make the call in a minute or so during the mayhem on the field and research showed around 25 percent of players confirmed as having concussion, through missing training or a game afterwards, had not been taken off in the game they suffered the head knock. In the past year, with the PSCA, research shows it now to be around 11 percent. It's still not good enough, but it has to be a step in the right direction."
© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
As widely predicted, All Black prop John Afoa has agreed to move to Gloucester at the end of the season after three years with Ulster
Manchester United were braced for the departure of former manager Sir Alex Ferguson, with the Times citing a document that warned his successor "may not be as successful as he has been"
Red Bull has named Sebastien Buemi and Antonio Felix da Costa as its reserve driver line-up for 2014
Phil Jagielka has admitted he feels sorry for his former manager David Moyes after his torrid start to life at Old Trafford but believes the Manchester United high-ups have let him down
Centuries from Michael Clarke and Brad Haddin put Australia in full command of the second Test in Adelaide as the hosts racked up 570 for 9 declared before Mitchell Johnson roared in to remove Alastair Cook