Next LIVE rugby on TV
to be announced
Wed, 31 Jul 2013 14:30:05 +0000
  • Switch Edition
ESPN SCRUM / Scotland / News
Paper Round
'Scotland have never been worse'
ESPN Staff
February 10, 2014
Where now for Scotland? © PA Photos

As the dust - or perhaps more accurately the mud - settles on a one-sided Calcutta Cup match, there is an overall sense of gloom in the media about the future for Scottish rugby.

Sir Clive Woodward leads the charge in the Daily Mail. "Saturday was a sad day for Scottish sport and their rugby team have never been worse. That team would fail to beat a single club in the Aviva Premiership and a second-string England side would have won comfortably. All the historic montages of this fixture, all the auld enemy stuff, looks a nonsense now and it will remain embarrassing until Scotland get a competitive team. "

Scotland on the rack

© PA Photos
  • Scotland last won the Five/Six Nations in 1999

    Their last Grand Slam was in 1990

    Since the Six Nations was expanded to include Italy, Scotland have lost 52 of the 72 matches played

    They have won only two of their last 12 fixtures

In the Times Owen Slot adopts a similar tone. "There is a bleaker reading of the evidence [Scotland] left out on the muddy stretches of Murrayfield that questions the sad realities of the professional game in the country and asks: are there really six nations in this tournament? If relegation and promotion were ever to come in to the Six Nations, Scotland, in their present state, would be eternal candidates for the drop. That would clearly accelerate the downward spiral. And yes, this remains a hypothetical debate, but for now the Six Nations Championship remains four plus two and devalued because of it."

Paul Hayward in the Daily Telegraph goes a step further. "Scotland should be told by the Six Nations Championship to start taking it seriously or step aside for another country to have a go. This may seem a melodramatic response to their lamentable 20-0 home defeat to England at the weekend but the Scots are becoming an embarrassment to one of sport's greatest tournaments."

And he concludes with a withering attack on those running the game in Scotland. "The great cauldron of Scottish union is now a heavily corporatised world of synthetic patriotism, firework bangs and pre-match cavorting by the Red Hot Chilli Pipers. You have only to leave Murrayfield in the dark to know that something has been lost. Scotland have weakened to the point where the best young players must have no faith in the bureaucrats who set the stage on which they play. Most of all, Scotland's supporters are being cheated by the 'Murrayfield experience' and by the paucity of resources on display.

Andy Bull in the Guardian has Scotland's interim coach Scott Johnson in his sights. "A man can expect to get away with the same old lines only so many times before his audience spot that he sounds like a stuck record. If a bad workman blames his tools, a bad coach carries on much as Johnson did after this match."

Stephen Jones in the Sunday Times agrees. "It would be wonderful to be proved wrong, but there is so little in the previous career of Johnson to suggest he is in any way suited by temperament, skills or knowledge of his adopted nation. Off the field, Johnson can be entertaining. But what Scotland need is to be entertained by wins, not words. One of the best Scottish players of recent times had this reaction to the prospect of Johnson taking complete charge: "Very scary." Quite."

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Football

  • Cricket

  • Rugby

    • Days
    • Hrs
    • Mins
    • Secs

    F1 - United States GP

  • OtherLive >>

    Golf - BMW Masters, Shanghai
    Tennis - Paris Masters
    Snooker - International Championship, Chengdu
  • Tennis

    Federer cruises as Djokovic sets up Murray tie

    Roger Federer maintained pressure on Novak Djokovic in the race for world No.1 status after a 6-4 6-4 win against Lucas Pouille earned him a place in the last eight at the Paris Masters, before the Serb saw off Gael Monfils to set up a clash with Andy Mur

  • Rugby

    Burgess ready for Bath challenge

    Sam Burgess has revealed his high-profile, six-figure switch of rugby codes was based on "the challenge" that will await him - and not next year's World Cup in England

  • Formula 1

    Rosberg on full attack mode for three races

    Nico Rosberg says the gloves can come off completely in his duel with Lewis Hamilton at the United States Grand Prix now Mercedes has wrapped up the constructors' championship

  • Formula 1

    Caterham and Marussia no-shows in breach of regulations

    FIA president Jean Todt will decide what action should be taken against Marussia and Caterham for missing this weekend's US Grand Prix after the stewards found both teams in breach of the regulations but opted not to impose a penalty

  • Formula 1

    Verstappen wants Vergne as Toro Rosso team-mate

    Max Verstappen wants Jean-Eric Vergne as his team-mate at Toro Rosso next year

Sponsored Links
Make $170 in 60 seconds!
Google Vs Facebook, 60 sec. knock out! Choose a champion, Become a Winner!
Make $25 in 1 Minute!
Start trading with the biggest broker! Register now to receive $25 for FREE!