ESPN SCRUM

/ Aviva Premiership 2013-14

/ News

Aviva Premiership
Saracens 'urgently seek to overturn' Melck's red card
ESPN Staff
May 10, 2014
Justin Melck is issued his marching orders by Greg Garner © Getty Images
Enlarge

Saracens say they will "urgently seek to overturn the red card" that was shown to flanker Justin Melck in the second-half of their 31-27 loss to Leicester at Welford Road on Saturday.

Saracens' statement

  • "The touch judge obviously thought he saw something, but he certainly didn't see what he thought. Justin made no contact with eye, a fact corroborated by the Leicester player afterwards. It was a simple human mistake, albeit a very disappointing mistake for a charming man playing perhaps his last competitive match for the club.
  • "Saracens will do everything possible to ensure this red card is rescinded. To their great credit, Leicester Tigers have offered their unequivocal support."

Melck was issued with a straight red card by referee Greg Garner, on the advice of the touch judge, in the 44th minute of the match for alleged contact with an opponent's eye. Melck looked bemused at the call and Sarries confirmed post-match they will appeal the decision in what could be his last game for the club.

"We are hugely disappointed with the decision," Saracens boss Mark McCall said. "It seems very unusual for a touch judge, who is in the position he was in, to make that kind of call and decide not to consult the fourth official.

"Their player did not complain and subsequently said it did not happen. To make a call of that magnitude with 40 minutes left is staggering. We will look to have the decision over-turned. Justin is not that kind of player, it was a dreadful decision."

McCall was backed by Leicester's director of rugby Richard Cockerill, who said: "Neil Briggs was the supposed victim and he said there was no eye-gouging. It was just a hand across the bottom of his face. He said it was a mistake by the officials.

"I don't think Melck is a dirty player and I don't think he did it. Hopefully, it will get resolved by the authorities."

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Rugby

    Rugby's influence on Seahawks' Super Bowl charge

    Seattle stand on the cusp of a second straight Super Bowl crown and it's in no small part to rugby and the game's tackling technique

  • Golf

    Tiger struggles to two over in first tournament of 2015

    The optimism and good vibe that Tiger Woods emitted in the days leading up to his first round of 2015 faded quickly on the front nine at the TPC Scottsdale, where a slew of mistakes led to a tough opening day that saw a glimmer over the closing holes

  • Rugby

    Video: America's new hitwoman is 'KO' for a reason

    Rugby is the fastest growing women's sport in the United States; that is until vision of Lindenwood University student Tianna Camous goes viral

  • Rugby

    No code switch regrets for Burgess

    Sam Burgess has had "no second thoughts" on chasing his World Cup dream despite finding it difficult to let go of his rugby league past

  • Football

    United to push again for Hummels

    Manchester United will make one last big push to sign either Mats Hummels of Borussia Dortmund or Aymeric Laporte of Athletic Bilbao over the last few days of the transfer window, club sources have told ESPN

Sponsored Links
Make $170 in 60 seconds!
Google Vs Facebook, 60 sec. knock out! Choose a champion, Become a Winner!
Make $25 in 1 Minute!
Start trading with the biggest broker! Register now to receive $25 for FREE!