PITTSBURGH -- This trade was too good for Joey Votto to turn down.
The Cincinnati Reds star first baseman spotted a fan sitting along the first base line Monday at PNC Park wearing a T-shirt that read "Votto for President." It was from a Nike promotional campaign in 2012 and Votto hadn't kept any of the shirts.
In the middle of the fourth inning, Votto walked over to the fan and asked for the shirt, offering an autographed jersey in return. The man agreed and the suddenly bare-chested fan and Votto exchanged first bumps along with Labor Day gifts.
"I was trying to find (the T-shirt) for a while and I was excited to see if I could trade a jersey for a shirt and he obliged," Votto said.
"He was willing to take his shirt off in the middle of the stands and thanks to him for being willing to do that," he said.
That was the highlight of the day for Votto, who went 1 for 4 and grounded into a double play as the Reds lost for the ninth time in 12 games.
Trevor Williams (12-9) continued his stretch of strong starts by pitching 6 2/3 scoreless innings. He allowed five hits while striking out four and walking one.
Williams improved to 6-2 with a 0.66 ERA in his last nine starts, giving up four runs in 54 2/3 innings. It was his ninth outing of at least five innings without allowing a run this season.
"It's trusting my stuff and being able to put the fastball where I want to put it," Williams said. "We go into every start knowing the fastball command is going to be there and everything comes off that. It's fun to throw the ball to all four quadrants of the strike zone."
Adam Frazier had career high-tying four hits, including a solo home run off Matt Harvey (6-8) in the first and a two-run single in the seventh that stretched the Pirates' lead to 5-0. Frazier also had a double and three RBI.
Polanco hit a two-run shot in the sixth inning that made it 3-0.
Gennett, the NL batting leader with a .320 average, broke up the Pirates' shutout bid with a solo drive off Kyle Crick in the eighth. Gennett also doubled in the first inning, but Williams worked out of a second-and-third jam with one out by striking Eugenio Suarez and getting Scott Schebler to fly out.
"He's kind of like the guy who can get you a stolen base when you need a stolen base," Pittsburgh manager Clint Hurdle said of Williams. "He had four strikeouts today, but he can get you a punchout when you need a punchout."
Harvey surrendered three runs and seven hits in six innings with three strikeouts and no walks.
"It was one of those (starts) where you look back and the numbers obviously don't go with how the game went but two pitches definitely cost me," Harvey said.
Pirates: C Elias Diaz (strained right hamstring) missed his third straight game.
Reds SS Blake Trahan was 1 for 3 in his major league debut, hitting a single off Williams in the seventh inning. He was promoted from Triple-A Louisville on Saturday.
Reds: LHP Cody Reed (0-1, 3.26 ERA) will make his third start and 13th relief appearance of the season Tuesday night after limiting Milwaukee to one run in 4 2/3 innings in his last outing.
Pirates: RHP Joe Musgrove (5-8, 3.80 ERA) is 1-4 in his last six starts despite a 3.65 ERA.
More AP baseball: https://apnews.com/tag/MLB and https://twitter.com/AP-Sports
Athletics' Bob Melvin nabs AL Manager of the Year honors
Oakland Athletics skipper Bob Melvin was named American League Manager of the Year on Tuesday after guiding the team with the lowest Opening Day payroll in baseball to a 97-65 record and its first playoff berth in four years.
Brian Snitker is NL's top manager after leading Braves to East title
After leading the Braves to an unexpected National League East title, Brian Snitker has been named NL Manager of the Year. The Brewers' Craig Counsell and Rockies' Bud Black finished second and third, respectively.
Did Ohtani deserve Rookie of the Year?
Around the Horn discuss whether Shohei Ohtani deserved Rookie of the Year even though he only played 104 games this season.
MLB to investigate claims of racial discrimination vs. Mariners
MLB said in a statement provided to The Athletic that it will investigate allegations of racial discrimination in the Seattle Mariners organization made by a former employee.
Time for Giants to decide what to do with Madison Bumgarner
Forget nostalgia. With Farhan Zaidi taking over the front office, San Francisco must re-evaluate how the hero of Octobers past fits into the franchise's future.
Phillies manager Gabe Kapler loses Malibu home in Woolsey Fire
Phillies manager Gabe Kapler is thankful his family is safe after his Malibu home was destroyed in the Woolsey Fire that has burned at least 435 buildings and is threatening tens of thousands more.