ESPN SCRUM

/ Top 14 Orange 2013-14

/ News

The concussion debate
Hape: Players are treated like pieces of meat
ESPN Staff
June 2, 2014
Shontayne Hape in action for England. He has sounded a warning against the dangers of concussion © Getty Images
Enlarge

Former England centre Shontayne Hape has accused coaches of treating players like "pieces of meat" after finally announcing his retirement from rugby.

Hape also sounded a warning against the dangers of concussion after being forced to call time on his playing career because of a series of head injuries.

Hape's last professional game was for Montpellier last year and, although he received medical advice to quit the sport in January, he has only just revealed his decision to retire and the shocking reasons for it.

Hape, 33, claims he was often put under pressure to return to action after head injuries before he was ready. He suffered more than 20 concussions and was frequently knocked out during his career, including several times in succession during the 2012-13 season at Montpellier. Subsequent scans revealed his brain function had been reduced to just above that of someone with special needs and he was advised to retire.

"Things got so bad I couldn't even remember my pin number - my card got swallowed up twice. My memory was shot," Hape told the New Zealand Herald. "The specialist explained that my brain was so traumatised, had swollen so big, that even just getting a tap to the body would knock me out. I had to retire immediately.

"I was thinking I'd rest for a year and then make a come back. That's why I never told anyone I was retired. I still couldn't accept it was over.

Hape, who won 13 caps for England, felt symptoms such as constant migraines, sensitivity to light and sound, irritability, depression and memory loss.

"There was constant pressure from the coaches [to play]," he said. "Most coaches don't care what happens later on in your life. It's about the here and now. Everyone wants success. They just think, 'If we pay you this you are going to do this'. Players are just pieces of meat. When the meat gets too old and past its use by date, the club just buys some more."

Hape also claimed that players regularly manipulate cognitive tests that are designed to monitor their brain functions throughout the season.

"In England it is a standard procedure for all players to perform a computerised pre-season head test. The test establishes a baseline score that you'll have to match later in the season if you cop a head knock.

"The problem with the test is that players can manipulate it by under-performing so that later if you have a head knock and you have to beat it you normally can.

"This is an issue people, particularly young players, need to know about. More people need to speak out about it, tell the truth if they are suffering. Most players won't, though, for fear of being thought of as soft or because of the financial pressures."

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Latest
  • Most Viewed
  • News
  • Features
  • Formula 1

    McLaren getting more from Honda PU - Button

    Jenson Button was in an optimistic mood following Friday practice in Malaysia after seeing McLaren make a step forward from its dismal Australian Grand Prix pace

  • Rugby

    Brown ruled out of Saracens clash with concussion

    England full-back Mike Brown has been ruled out of Harlequins' Premiership showdown with Saracens at Wembley after showing signs of concussion after the Six Nations win over France

  • Football

    Bans for Real Madrid fans who kicked Gareth Bale's car

    Three Real Madrid fans are set to be fined €3,001 each and banned from attending all games for six months after kicking and punching the cars of Blancos players, including that of Gareth Bale, on the night of the team's 2-1 defeat at Barcelona

  • Rugby

    Lions spoil Cooper's Reds return

    The Lions have rounded out a fine Australasian tour with a third win from four matches, an 18-17 triumph over the struggling Queensland Reds in Brisbane

  • Formula 1

    Who said what after Friday practice

    ESPN rounds up all the reaction from up and down the paddock after Friday practice for the Malaysian Grand Prix

  • Formula 1

    F1 cost cutting: Not putting money where the mouth is

    Mudslinging and an agreement on something that will never happen, it's all in a day's work for a Formula One boss, as Maurice Hamilton explains...

  • Rugby

    Unsavoury sledging did not end with Potgieter

    Fallout continues from the NSW-Brumbies derby, with one Tahs forward - not Potgieter - surprised by other unsavoury comments during the game, Greg Growden reports

  • Rugby

    Super Rugby preview, team news, line-ups: Round 7

    Greg Growden previews Super Rugby round 7. We've also got key stats, team news and all the line-ups to inform your ESPN Footytips Super Rugby picks

  • Formula 1

    Storm clouds gather in Malaysia

    Will Mercedes dominate again? Can anybody catch up with the help of a rainstorm? And will the Red Bull/Renault relationship tear itself apart? All those questions and more will be answered at this weekend's Malaysian Grand Prix

  • Formula 1

    Alonso: More questions than answers

    Maurice Hamilton pieces together what we know from the Fernando Alonso crash and explains why the latest answers raise more questions

  • News
  • Features
  • Inside Boxing

    'I've sparred with Klitschko and Fury - now I want Joshua'

    Unbeaten heavyweight Dillian Whyte, 28, (14-0, 11 KOs) tells ESPN where his rivalry with Anthony Joshua stems from and outlines the plan for his career this year after returning from a doping ban in November

  • UFC

    Top 10 best UFC fighters of all time

    Some of the best fighters to ever glove up have plied their trade in the Octagon - now ESPN list the 10 best who have fought under the UFC banner

  • Ask Steven

    Home front

    Who was the first Briton to win the British Grand Prix?

  • Ask Steven

    Pointless drivers

    Where does Anthony Davidson's record of 24 Grands Prix without a point rank him?

  • Ask Steven

    Home favourites

    How many F1 drivers have had one win, but done it at their home Grand Prix?

Sponsored Links

Make Huge Income from your Home
Download your Free Guide And Learn How To Increase Your Monthly Income