Next LIVE rugby on TV
to be announced
Wed, 31 Jul 2013 14:30:05 +0000
  • Switch Edition
ESPN SCRUM / ESPNscrum Columnist
Greg Growden
Greg Growden | Columnist Index
After more than 30 years with The Sydney Morning Herald and Fairfax Media in Australia, Greg Growden now writes exclusively online for ESPNscrum. Never afraid to step on toes, you can expect plenty of compelling insight from one of Australia's most renowned rugby writers.
Greg Growden writes ...
Wallabies effective, just what they needed
Greg Growden
November 25, 2013
Israel Folau sliced through the Scotland defence after a lovely inside ball from Quade Cooper © Getty Images

KPIs: How we rate the Wallabies

  • Result: Like most recent Australia-Scotland Test matches, this was grim, dim and in the end a bit of a dirge. The Wallabies stuck at it, and won, but it far from memorable.
  • Scrum: There weren't many, but the Wallabies held up. Interesting the back-row reverted to its usual blindside-openside flanker combination after going left and right against Ireland.
  • Defence: Fine, but helped by Scotland playing so deep in attack, and without much idea. Scotland just don't know how to score tries.
  • Combinations: Not surprisingly after losing centre pairing Matt Toomua and Tevita Kuridrani, it was disjointed at times. Israel Folau saved the day out wide.
  • Attacking mojo: Again Folau fixed up the problems, while Quade Cooper had his moments. Unlikely they will stick with Christian Leali'ifano at No 13.
  • Overall mark: Seven out of 10.
  • Greg Growden's original KPIs
  • England Test: Scrum unable to provide platform
  • Italy Test: Turin win a step forwards
  • Ireland Test: Wallabies still not entitled to party

The Edinburgh Test match was a case of the Wallabies, in trying times, keeping it simple, getting in, doing the job, and getting out of there as soon as they could. It was a sound performance by Australia, which was never going to spectacular after losing four key attacking players through injury, suspension and late night shenanigans. With a revamped backline, there was always going to be mishaps, and missed calls, but thankfully Quade Cooper and Israel Folau showed the required level of composure to get on top of an opposition who were not much more than a bunch of scrappers.

Although lacking talent and nous, Scotland always somehow fluster the Wallabies, because their prime aim is to obstruct and destruct. They effectively slow down the opposition play, burrowing away and falling all over the place at the breakdown, ensuring that Test matches are fractured affairs. Their plan is further aided by regularly playing on a rice paddy field, otherwise known as Murrayfield. And when you have such an irritating referee as Jaco Peyper in charge, the South African who gets a real kick out of blowing up every breakdown, it turns into a tedious, often painful, occasion.

There wasn't much beauty in this Test, but at least Folau gave us enough moments of attacking gloss to stop us nodding off. Folau's understanding of how Cooper plays is improving in every Test, and they have now become a productive and dangerous combination. Like Digby Ioane, Folau is aware of the rewards that come from being a blowfly around Cooper, who relishes putting a large, creative athlete into space. Cooper has the ball skills and sense of timing, and Folau the physique, pace and prowess to finish it off, as shown when the Wallabies playmaker threw his fullback the perfect pass that led to the newcomer's ninth Test try. From turnover play, Cooper was smart enough to notice lumbering Scottish forwards hovering in midfield, and he gave Folau the ball, knowing the fullback could show them up. Folau skipped through the Scotland defenders as if they were battered witch's hats.

Australia were effective in grinding out a tough victory (video available only in Australia)

The other encouraging sign was that of James Horwill starting to find form. After being way off the pace for most of the year, which may have had something to do with playing with injuries, Horwill produced his most prominent performance of the year. He was dominant at lineout time, while his defence and general field work was notable.

The Wallabies' lineout performance was probably their best feature, succeeding in destabilising Scotland, especially when the home team had the throw. But the Wallabies forwards again suffered through poor discipline, with the latest yellow card victim being Rob Simmons for a harebrained retaliatory punch to an opponent.

As for the Dublin Six who had to watch from the sidelines, Adam Ashley-Cooper will come straight back in against Wales, most probably at outside centre as Christian Leali'ifano appeared off the pace. Leali'ifano goal kicking was astray and he was caught out of position when Scotland made one of their few attacking plays during the second half. Joe Tomane and Chris Feauai-Sautia made the most of their occasional chances out on the wings, but Nick Cummins should still take one of their spots for the Cardiff tour ender.

The Wallabies' forwards are performing well enough to overcome Wales next Saturday. But it will be more a case of whatever backline Ewen McKenzie comes up with having the ability to match an opposition who are also bound to play wide. Whoever makes the most from opposition attacking mistakes and fractured play will win this Test. So the Wallabies have an enormous advantage with Folau on their side.

Did Chris Feauai-Sautia do enough to retain a starting berth against Wales? © Getty Images

© ESPN Sports Media Ltd
Join the conversation with Greg on Twitter @GregGrowden

Live Sports

Communication error please reload the page.

  • Football

    Arsenal facing UEFA crowd probe over flares

    Arsenal will face UEFA charges for "insufficient organisation" following Wednesday's Champions League clash with Galatasaray, during which flares were thrown onto pitch by the Turkish side's fans

  • Golf

    McIlroy off the pace at Carnoustie

    World number one Rory McIlroy was struggling to reproduce his Ryder Cup form on the opening day of the Alfred Dunhill Links Championship on Thursday

  • Football

    Solution to Sturridge injury saga 'amicable'

    Brendan Rodgers believes England boss Roy Hodgson has learned a lesson over the Daniel Sturridge injury saga, but says their handling of the issues was "amicable."

  • Football

    Alves set to leave Barcelona for England

    Barcelona full-back Dani Alves has said he is leaving the club at the end of the season for a move to England, according to a report

  • Cricket

    Strauss fears for Test cricket

    Andrew Strauss, the former England captain, and an increasingly influential voice in cricket administration, has issued dire warnings about the survival of Test cricket

Sponsored Links
Make $170 in 60 seconds!
Google Vs Facebook, 60 sec. knock out! Choose a champion, Become a Winner!
Make $25 in 1 Minute!
Start trading with the biggest broker! Register now to receive $25 for FREE!